Position Battles Aplenty as Spring Camps Open
by Chuck
Spring Training camps officially open this week with teams beginning the process of getting ready for the long road which is your typical major league season. Even before the official opening, some players have been spotted around the various spring facilities they call home, some as early arrivals, others as permanent residents of the neighborhood.
Some guys, like Kevin Millar with the Royals, are non-roster invitees trying to hang on for another year, others, like Cleveland’s Grady Sizemore, reported early as they continue to rehab from late season injuries or off-season surgeries.
While there are few exceptions, some teams, whether it be possible playoff contenders or teams just looking to improve over last season, not only have openings on the 25 man roster, but in the everyday lineup.
Some of the more notable, or obvious.
Blue Jays: The only catcher on the 40 man roster is former Royal John Buck. No fewer than five non-roster candidates, led by top prospect JP Arencibia, are in camp looking not only to secure the back-up job, but potentially take the job from Buck.
Red Sox: For the first time in a couple of years, the Red Sox enter the spring pretty well set. The only true opening on the roster is an up the middle backup for Dustin Pedroia and Marco Scutaro. Jed Lowrie is available in a pinch to fill in for Scutaro at short, but has no experience at second. With Mike Lowell now the primary backup at third and first, there really is no need for Lowrie’s lack of versatility. Former Brewer Billy Hall is in camp with the hopes he wins the super sub role, he’s played everywhere except first base and catcher during his career. If Hall doesn’t hit during the spring and can’t make the squad, the only true middle infielder available is non-roster invitee Gil Velasquez, a 30 year old journeyman with nine career ML games.
Yankees: Most of the off-season gossip regarding the Bronx Bombers surrounds the battle for the fifth starter role…a battle which doesn’t exist. If Phil Hughes can’t hold onto the job during the spring, there are a number of candidates in camp capable of filling the role. The acquisition of Randy Winn solves the left field situation, leaving the only realistic competition the backup catching role to Jorge Posada. With Posada starting to see more DH time, the Yanks feel Francisco Cervelli to be lacking the necessary experience to deal with a veteran staff, the experience so adequately shown the past couple of years by the now departed Jose Molina. To that end, former Brewers catcher Mike Rivera is in camp as a non-roster player and is expected to make the team as Posada’s right hand man.
Twins: The Twins have a total of three outfielders on their 40 man roster, and recently released backup candidate Jason Pridie. In camp with a chance at the backup spot is 35 year old Jacque Jones and prospect Ben Revere.
Rangers: Counting non roster players, the Texas Rangers have twenty eight position players in camp, with just two being first baseman. One is incumbent Chris Davis, the other, 2008 first round draft pick and non-roster invitee Justin Smoak. Considering Davis won the regular job coming out of last year’s spring training and still found himself being sent down, the question isn’t if Smoak wins the job, but when. The answer to that question could come as soon as Opening Day.
Phillies: As is the case with their World Series opponents, the Phillies have an All-Star caliber player at each infield position, and like the Yankees, a long-term injury to any of them would be a disaster. On the corners, the Phils have a couple of lefty hitting, one dimensional players in Greg Dobbs and Ross Gload, up the middle they are even thinner, with only former Dodger scrubeenie Juan Castro in camp as the potential backup for Jimmy Rollins and Chase Utley.
Cardinals: Being the backup to Albert Pujols is akin to being the understudy to Michael Crawford in the Broadway show Phantom of the Opera…you get a regular paycheck but you don’t get to perform very often. Minor league slugger Allen Craig is the only other player in camp with first base experience, considering he’s a corner outfielder by trade and the Cards’ are lacking in backup candidates for both Ryan Ludwick and Matt Holliday, Craig is almost assured at worst a long look in camp. The Cardinals also have a fifth starter battle going on, a battle with more of a cloudy outlook. Other than former Cub Rich Hill, the remaining candidates are mostly minor leaguers, leaving the potential for a gaping hole the Cards must fill if they hope to defend their Central title.
Reds: Some prognosticators believe the Reds to be the National League’s sleeper team in 2010. Despite missing thirty games due to a non-baseball related illness in 2009, first baseman Joey Votto posted a split of .322/25/84 which garnered him some MVP votes. The problem is the Reds have no viable backup in camp capable of filling in if he can’t stay healthy. Super sub candidate Todd Frazier can play the right corner but has yet to make his ML debut. The Reds have 2008 first rounder Yonder Alonso in camp and have talked about moving Votto to left field, but recent rumors have the Reds considering moving Alonso behind the plate.
Diamondbacks: In his NL West preview airing on MLB Network, analyst Mitch Williams said of the DBacks, “they could win 95 games or lose 95, with everything hanging on Brandon Webb.” The NL Cy Young winner in 2007 and the runner-up in both ’06 and ’08, made just one start in 2009 before going out with a shoulder injury which eventually required surgery. While Webb remains optimistic he’ll be ready by opening day, his out pitch is the sinker, a pitch solely dependent on the shoulder. It’s unlikely this to be the case, and with top prospect Jarrod Parker out for the year after his own surgery (Tommy John), the Dbacks are in trouble pitching wise, despite the off-season acquisitions of Edwin Jackson and Ian Kennedy. Triple A prospect Bryan Augenstein was hammered in a brief major league trial and also in the Arizona Fall League, leaving the Dbacks hoping for the best from Webb.
Dodgers: As with their division counterparts, the Dodgers have an opening for the fifth starter role. Unlike their division counterparts, however, the candidates the Dodgers have in camp are major league caliber pitchers; Jeff Weaver, Russ and Ramon Ortiz. The memories of Russ Ortiz in a Diamondbacks uniform are unpleasant to say the least, but he’s still a better option than Bryan Augenstein.
Spring Training is six weeks long only because it’s a money maker for the organizations; no player salaries are paid, operating costs are underwritten by the host cities and expenses are limited because the minor and major leaguers train in the same locale. In this day and age of high salaries, most players don’t work during the off-season, they spend their time, assumedly, staying in somewhat reasonable shape.
That doesn’t mean, however, all jobs are guaranteed, nor that all jobs are locked at the beginning. Guys get hurt, others get passed by younger (and cheaper) talent, or the team might have to keep someone they don’t want to because of option or waiver rules.
For the elite, the next six weeks are a rehearsal for what lies ahead, no reason to go all out, no reason to risk injury for what amounts as a meaningless instance in a meaningless game.
For everyone else, the next six weeks are all about meaning.


February 17th, 2010 at 10:37 am
Chuck, have you looked at Randy Winn’s stats from last year? .262/.318/.353/.671 75 OPS+ 2 HR, 16 SB
I’m not sure what the Yanks are thinking but if Gardner doesn’t start in LF they’re nuts.
February 17th, 2010 at 10:53 am
This is the first time I have read that Cervelli isn’t good with veteran pitching. He will be the back up catcher and compared to Molina he is a speedster.
February 17th, 2010 at 11:33 am
I think in all aspects of the game, Winn’s still a better player than Gardner.
The Yanks apparently do too, otherwise there would have been no reason to sign him.
http://newyork.yankees.mlb.com/team/depth_chart/index.jsp?c_id=nyy
February 17th, 2010 at 12:13 pm
I don’t agree, Winn is 36 and declining. I hated the Winn move because Hairston did a good job backing up everywhere. There is no room on the most expensive ML team for a .671 OPS, especially in a corner OF slot.
Winn instead of Damon is going to hurt them in the long run.
I think the reason why the Yanks signed Winn is because he was +31 on his rtot fielding, which represents over half of his career total! So it’s probably just a statistical anomaly. Gardner is much faster, younger and better already, IMO.
February 17th, 2010 at 12:30 pm
It just seems to me with all the off-season talk around trying to get anyone with a pulse to play LF tells me the Yanks aren’t all that excited about Gardner playing everyday.
There’s no question Winn wasn’t their first choice and he probably wasn’t in their top five, yet here we are.
I’ve been wrong before and will be again, but I’m more confident in the LF situation than I am with Hughes/Joba, and to me THAT’S a no-brainer.
This is why they have spring training, right?
February 17th, 2010 at 12:30 pm
The Twins traded Johan Santana for what? 4 players? And none of them are on the Major League roster 3 years later? What’s up?
Yankees and Redsox…when your concern is a 5th starter and a back-up infielder, you’re in pretty damn good shape.
Los Angeles Dodgers – I thought you wrote Ramon Martinez, not Ramon Ortiz. Anyway, I used to wonder what could have been with Ramon Martinez. It seemed like he had good stuff…just couldn’t put it together and stay healthy, I guess.
Cincinnati Reds – Joey Votto can hit. Let’s see what happens with Jay Bruce. Bruce needs to improve big-time.
You posted no comment on the Royals, but what’s your opinion of Alex Gordon? Is this guy ever going to be a quality major leaguer? He’s only 26 and it looks like he’s finished.
February 17th, 2010 at 1:16 pm
“Phillies:”
My problem with the Phillies is that their bench and pen are both really bad.
I agree with you Chuck 100% that if the Phils have to go to Gload, Dobbs, or Castro long term they are in a world of hurt.
Last year at one point the starting infield at AAA was: Andy Tracy (36) Pablo Ozuna (35) Miguel Cairo (35) Mike Cervenak (33)
And I’m still not impressed with having Francisco and possibly Mayberry Jr. in the OF.
I do like Schneider as to me he’s a better defensive catcher and Ruiz’s CS% is bad and he is to me a suspect hitter yet the Phils gave him three more years.
And the Pen with injuries to Lidge and Romero will be off to a less than stellar start. Madson has proved that he can’t close. So hopefully he can set up for Baez.
Also the local Philly sports guru’s are saying that the Phils are likely to go with Escalona to replace Romero instead of Bastardo.
And that if Moyer can’t hack the 5th starters spot it will be up to Bastardo, Kendrick, or Contreras.
I’d like to see them give Drew Carpenter a shot at the 5th starter or a pen spot. He was easily the best pitcher in AAA they had last year. Far better than Carrasco who for some reason was so prized by the Indians.
February 17th, 2010 at 1:51 pm
I like Gordon, actually.
I just think the Royals screwed with his head too much. Here’s this big college star/top draft pick and the first thing they try and do is change his position..all because of Mark Teahen?
It took them two and a half seasons to realize Teahen has the most versatility, the Royals should have just stuck Gordon at first, batted him at the bottom of the order and left him alone.
Defensively, he’s upper tier, offensively, while he won’t have Evan Longoria’s power, he should still hit .300.
I think this will be his breakout season.
February 17th, 2010 at 5:31 pm
Apparently Mitch Williams of MLB Network believes Brandon Webb is worth 28 wins to the Diamondbacks. I understand the hyperbole, but so many front line baseball analysts are idiots.
February 17th, 2010 at 10:31 pm
I don’t know why you mention the Cardinals’ backup 1B role when it’s a complete non-issue. LaRussa slots whoever he feels into first base, figuring–largely correctly–that it’s not going to matter that much. Jim Edmonds, Mike Matheny, Adam Kennedy, and other people not first basemen by trade have seen time there. It’s hardly a “position battle” in 2010
February 17th, 2010 at 11:04 pm
If the Cardinals back-up first basemen makes an impact in the 2010 season, the Cardinals are screwed.
February 19th, 2010 at 1:42 pm
Competition pushes people. If Gardner is better than Winn then it is up to him to win the job. He needs to PROVE it and win the spot. On first glance the loss of Damon looks like it will hurt the Yanks. But considering their upgrade in center field, Damon’s age, Damon’s poor defense, and the lack of left handed hitting LF’s in this year’s free agent class, the Yanks made some great moves…
PS… the Yankees AAA afiliate (Pittsburgh Pirates) have some good young OF prospects and when one of them breaks out… a spot will await him in the Bronx
February 19th, 2010 at 1:48 pm
Can somebody give me an answer???
Why don’t the Red Sox give Jermaine Dye a job?
The Sox could use the power that Dye (even at his age) can provide…
Fenway is a great park for a slow left fielder…
Fenway is a perfect park for a right hand hitting power guy…
AND it seems like Dye is going to have to settle for a lot less money no matter who signs him…
Seems to me like a good match
February 19th, 2010 at 5:13 pm
Bob: RE the RS and Dye. They don’t have a place for him. He won’t start and can only play LF or DH. If they need a RH DH for a game or two, they’ll put Martinez there for the gave and a start to Tec. The plan seems to be to go with only 4 OFs plus Bill Hall and in the case of an injury they’d rather call up Josh Reddick or Ryan Kalish and give them a few games and AB in the majors.
March 4th, 2010 at 6:48 am
I don’t understand why pitchers like Russ Ortiz are still being signed by major league teams despite their lack of success in recent years. Same goes for Jason Jennings who hasn’t had a winning record since 2002 and Daniel Cabrera without a winning record since 2004. Worst of all pitchers like these are preventing minor league pitchers from getting their shot at the majors.
Ortiz, Jennings and Cabrera have already proven they can’t pitch so at least let a minor leaguer show whether they can pitch or not.